19th May 2009 17:52
HI, I don't have either but I thought I'd post the
www.which.co.uk reviews of both for you:-
MOTHERCARE MY4 score 68%
The Mothercare My4 travel system is a good choice for taller people, but not easy enough to use to be a Best Buy.
Summing it up, our experts said: 'It's unfortunate that the folding, removing parts and adjusting are so difficult, otherwise this would be a brilliant travel system'.
It is comfortable to push; we like that the horizontal foam handlebar, which adjusts from 93-107cm, increases the distance from the pushchair giving taller people more leg room. But the handle wobbles slightly when you apply pressure to it.
Good for newborn babies, it's a versatile beast. The reversible seat unit transforms easily into a long, narrow carrycot, or you can use the chassis with the Mothercare child car seat provided.
The whole seat reclines using buttons on the side, or you can recline the backrest separately using a stiff strap on the back that requires two hands to operate.
It's definitely one for smaller children, the seat is fairly narrow with a very short backrest and variable harness anchor points. It comes with a hood with viewing window and footmuff that converts into an apron.
The pushchair has pneumatic rear tires and is very wide at the back.
You need to remove the seat before folding and the chassis folds down to a reasonable 31x77x63cm (150 litres) which will fit in the boot of a mid-sized car. Getting the seat off is a real challenge though, as it is hard to unclip. Weight 12.2kg.
Pros: Self-catching clip, stands upright when folded, carry handle, padded harness, one button brake application, numbered folding sequence
Cons: No adjustable leg support, storage box seems small
QUINNY BUZZ 4 (a best buy! score 78%)
The Best Buy Quinny Buzz Travel System was a real hit with our testers, who found it easy to use, highly manoeuvrable and comfortable to drive on a wide range of surfaces. But it’s bulky, and on-board storage is poor.
The Buzz has a reversible seat unit that can be attached quickly and simply to face forward or backward.
The pneumatic tyres give an exceptionally smooth ride on all surfaces, from pavements and kerbs to stairs and off-road, but the wheel base is too wide to negotiate bus gangways easily.
It’s suitable from birth to 20kg, though the seat is small and doesn’t recline into a flat position for sleeping.
At 290 litres (42x104x65cm) the Buzz is huge when folded, but it fits into a medium-sized car boot – albeit with little room to spare – and the wheels are removable with a quick release mechanism.
The Buzz weighs 14.4kg, which is very heavy for a pushchair, and lacks a carry handle, so it’s not very portable. The handlebar can be adjusted for taller or shorter users.
By far the most unpopular thing about the Buzz is the clip-on storage bag; it’s hard to access items at the bottom, and hangs so low that it can catch the carer’s feet as they push.
The Quinny Buzz includes a hood with window, raincover and seat liner. It’s compatible with the Maxi Cosi car seat and Dreami carrycot, both available as optional extras.
The covers are removable but not machine washable, and some stains remain after wiping down.
Pros: Reversible seat unit, excellent on bumpy ground and off-road, good manoeuvrability
Cons: Huge, very heavy, storage bag is poor
hth!